Pilgrim Pipeline Holdings LLC has proposed the construction of a 178-mile pipeline through New York State to transport Bakken Crude oil, prompting the passage of 30 resolutions of opposition due to concerns for water and environmental quality degradation and the potential for spills. Based on our findings, we suggest that the state avoid permitting the Pilgrim Pipeline and instead focus on fixing existing fossil fuel infrastructure and implementing renewable energy technologies in accordance with the NYS Energy Plan for 2030.